Concert Review: Asian Youth Orchestra 2010As usual, there were 2 concerts in succession.
August 11, CCCH
Conductor: Richard Pontzious; Cello Soloist: Alban Gerhardt
All Strauss
Although I am not enamored of the conducting of Pontzious, I went for the Don Quixote. The orchestra played very well, and I think this incarnation is better than last year's in the winds and brass departments. For my taste, the big moments were too controlled and underplayed; youngsters should have fun with the cacophony! This made the piece a little too introspective and serious. Soloist Alban Gerhardt (he has an interesting website and a nice blog) was marvelous, coaxing a beautiful and refined tone from his cello. Most notable also was the lady viola soloist, who played sinuously, with phrasing that much belied her age. That was some of the best viola playing I have ever heard. During applause, Gerhardt nicely and generously gave her credit several times, outnumbering his token appreciation of the concertmaster and others. She deserved it. There was no encore.
I skipped the second half, as I am not fond of the Rosenkavalier waltzes (though I love the opera). And Don Juan needs a really great conductor to make it shine.
August 12, CCCH
Conductor: James Judd; Cello Soloist: Alban Gerhardt
Schumann-Mahler
This concert was better attended than the last. The Schumann cello concerto was beautifully played by Gerhardt, but the accompaniment was a little subdued; the reduced orchestra was probably not a great idea. Applause was plentiful and a sublime Bach encore was offered. Gerhardt's phrasing was totally natural and his variation of timber masterly, all the while maintaining the tempo. "Better than Rostropovich!", my friend said.
I had high expectations of James Judd, and he immediately showed his colors with the Mahler Symphony No. 5. The opening Funeral March and the ensuing movement were beautifully balanced and unfolded inexorably, with a momentum lacking in recent HKPO performances. The Adagietto was beautifully judged, never at the risk of lapsing into soap. The fly in the ointment was that the Scherzo and Rondo Finale that flanked it were a little too studied by half. A little more earthiness and wildness rather than refinement would have been welcome. Nonetheless, the finale was rousing. Overall the playing was marvelous and more even than last year. Gerhardt was playing in this piece in the cello section, sitting all the way back. What a thoughtful musician!
Appendix:
Here is what Gerhardt wrote about his experience with the AYO on his Blog:
"...Almost 25 years ago I joined the Federal Youth Orchestra of Germany (BJO) in which I played altogether for three years every summer, Easter and winter (and one extra session I don’t remember when). This absolutely changed my life as a musician because it brought me together with young people like me, talented and dedicated to music, different to the other kids in school, sometimes outsiders, but never really geeks or nerds. Playing music together in an orchestra after practising all these years on my own was mind-blowing, an experience so elevating that after the first session I just knew that I would not want to have any other profession than playing music, for the rest of my life. When I was asked to play five concerts with the Asian Youth Orchestra I agreed, first a bit half-heartedly because I wanted to provide real good summer holidays for my son János, but then nostalgia took over and I wanted to relive the time in a youth orchestra.
Two weeks ago we arrived in Hong Kong, Janos and me. The AYO had gracefully accepted inviting him along myself, and in these two weeks we absolutely had a blast together, playing concerts, travelling from Hong Kong to Shenzhen and Seoul for these five concerts, but also doing fun stuff like wind surfing in Cheung Chau, visiting the fun Ocean Park, beautifull located on the other side of Hong Kong island, shopping, playing games and in the pool, reading and just enjoying the wonderful food and restaurants in these Asian cities. But for me even more fulfilling was the artistic experience. With conductor (and friend) James Judd I performed three times the Schumann Concerto, participating twice in my fery first Mahler Symphony ever (No.5) in the second half, and with the founding conductor Richard Pontzious we did Richard Strauss’ Don Quixote, one of my all-time favorite orchestral works - always glad to play it, even though I find it harder than a “proper” cello concerto.
From the first rehearsal on I was amazed by the abiltiy of these youngsters from ten Asian countries to really listen to what I was doing, especially in the Schumann. At yesterdays last performance in Seoul I felt inspired to take as much freedom as I hardly ever do, because I knew they would be with me. For me the amount of freedom depends on the willingness and abilty of the people collaborating, because for me the most important goal is the over-all performance, not just my little part. I am play so freely that nobody can actually be (and feel) with me, it just feels (and sounds) wrong to me, and yesterday I felt I could do anything coming through my mind and the AYO and James would be there already! The Don Quixotte is obviously much less of a concerto, but even there we had some wonderful interaction and at certain passages we all were very spontaneous. I felt really sad leaving the orchestra last night, not because I did sooo much bonding with them (as I said, I was being mainly father and soloist, not too much time to share time with the other musicians, and much as I would have loved to), but because I enjoyed making music with them.
They will continue the tour to China and Japan with wonderful cellist Jian Wang taking over, and I am sure it will be a great experience for them doing the same pieces with another soloist who will bring his view and different ideas onto the stage. Janos and me are sitting at Hong Kong airport on our way to a five-day-escape to Phuket, Thailand, before school starts next week. Hopefully some more windsurfing there…."
No comments:
Post a Comment